Simon doesn’t sleep well. Simon has never slept well. The poor child may never sleep well. Our attempts to help him sleep better have resulted in him sleeping on the floor. He sleeps under ten blankets, including his weighted one. He sleeps on top of three pillows. There is cardboard blocking his entire window, leaving him the pitch black when his lights are off, his door is closed, and a towel is adjusted in front of the crack under his door. A personally mixed selection of white noise plays from an app on old, nearly dead iPhone while the lullaby versions of Smiths songs play on repeat all night. Since his first year we’ve read and followed the most scientific and plausible sleep book we could find, regulating his sleep times, getting him to bed abnormally, for modern society at least, early, following a bedtime routine.
And still, about 1/3 to 1/2 of his nights, Simon does not sleep well. We get a tiny face, inches from our own, at 2 am, requesting a pull up change. We leave our own door open, so when the lights pop on at 3:30, we can shuffle the reading boy back into bed. We get books thrown at us at 4:30 when the reading boy is more tired, more cranky, and less willing. And all three of us wake up the next morning irritable and pouty.
I’ve seen in postings far and wide that kids with autism and other neurological, sensory disorders respond well to melatonin, it’s largely without side effects, and is easy to use. Most said it helped with sleep onset, not night waking, and Simon has no trouble with sleep onset. We decided it couldn’t hurt to try, and bought a little bottle of sleep liquid. After a few days of slowly increasing his dosage to be sure we gave him the smallest amount possible, it worked! He nodded off to sleep easier and faster and stayed asleep all night. It even helped mellow out the bedtime battle, leaving him more willing to brush his teeth and get tucked in. After a few days he started asking for his sleepy time drops. He had no daytime grogginess, no physical reactions, and told us it helped him sleep. And for about a month, we all slept happily and praised the drops.
And then, the violence increased. Drastically. Our four year old who had been getting control of his anger, was able to hit the couch instead of us, or yell instead of kick, or even dive under blankets and take deep breaths to calm down, started screaming, flailing, punching, headbutting, kicking, spitting, and throwing every day. It lasted longer, had more intensity, and happened more often. Simon was an uncontrollable monster. We tried sticking more rigidly to a schedule, employing all our calm and all our strategies to help the poor guy calm down. It didn’t work.
With protests from Simon, we stopped the melatonin. Within a week, he was calmer, nicer, and more in control. He asked for the drops several times, but he still fell asleep okay, and his behavior was drastically better. And his sleep? Interrupted again, waking in the wee hours and staying awake until an hour or two before my alarm. It was certainly worth a try, but not worth the side effects. And so we move on, keeping our strategies in place, hoping for the best, and curbing our crabbiness at 6 am.







Comments
Lori
I’m intrigued…has anyone else seen these side effects? I have 2 children who have taken melatonin for years now, Booga is up til midnight without it…but since it’s been so long, I wouldn’t be able to say if the anger problems are worse with it or not…might be worth a summer experiment!
The Slacker Mom
We’ve been on melatonin for over a year and have just recently (past month) seen an increase in aggression and biting in one of our sons but I don’t know that I would attribute it to melatonin just yet. Everyone involved thinks there is a growth spurt spurring it on combined with a huge change in schedule after school ended. I might have to revisit the melatonin if things don’t start to straighten out in the next few weeks though. I really don’t know if we can go back to a wanderer at all hours of the night- not with 3 kids under 4 sharing a room!
Lalita
I’m not a medical professional, obviously, but I do think it’d be odd to develop a side affect so long after being on it. I hope for your sakes it’s not the melatonin! Ive only seen it listed as a “rare” side effect.
Since writing this we’ve given it to him a few times, but only in dire situations, to help him get back to a schedule when he’s way off. We have no trouble if it’s just one night, for whatever reason it didn’t happen until it built up in his system.
Sherri
Our son also has had the same reaction. It helps him sleep beautifully but the changes in his personality (anger, frustration, aggresion) are just not bearable. We have tested this out 2 times with the same results. It is so frustrating to have something help him sleep so well but yet have such a nasty side-effect. The doctors have looked at us like we’re crazy and it couldn’t possibly be true. I’m so sorry your family has had the same experience.
Heather
My 4 year old has been on it for about a year….we use 1 mg sub-lingual tablets…he only takes between 1 and 3 of them…depending on the day. I haven’t noticed any extra aggression…but he’s a busy guy to begin with. I notice it more when he doesn’t get enough sleep
I’m sorry they didn’t work for you.
Heather
Now Zyrtec, that makes my guy NUTS!
Misti
We tried the melatonin, and sometimes it made our daughter sleep, other times it seemed to hype her up. The pediatrician was baffled by this because the way melatonin works in the body shouldn’t be able to hype anyone! But, all of us have different body chemistry – such as benadryl makes her hyper when it makes our middle child sleepy – so I guess this just isn’t for her.
I hope you can figure out a way to get him to stay asleep – its hard when you feel like you have had a newborn for 5 years! I know exactly how you feel!! are you using any kind of visual boards? maybe you could make one for things to do when we wake up at night…
Solitary canary
It works in gifted children. And there are only side effects like the described effects above when given to the child every night.
Melatonin Induces REM sleep. Too many nights of rem sleep and you aren’t getting enough deep sleep. If you use melatonin in children I suggest you also use it on yourself. Too many consecutive nights of nonstop rem sleep leaves the brain and body more exhausted. The brain needs a break from all that activity. I give it every other day when sleep issues emerge.