Ms. Snark, meet Mama Bear.

Buddy will be two in less than a week. Since he is not really talking, his therapists put in for a speech evaluation. She arrived 20 minutes late and stayed less than half an hour. She interacted with him very little and asked me few questions. One question she did ask is what have we done for speech so far with his therapists. I answered that his OT and DT have not focused on this as that it is not their area, but that we do some signing and PECS. PECS, in our case, were lots of little pictures from things in our daily life that were Velcroed into folder pages where Bud could pick between choices, a way to begin communication without words. Bud was too interested in the Velcro. All he wanted to do was rip rip rip the Velcro and toss the pictures. It was a fun sensory activity,though! The speech evaluator responded without missing a beat by saying ”the PECS didn’t not work, it was that the therapist who did it with you obviously did it wrong and was incompetent and not certified. I am certified and know how to us this properly.” Wow. It gets worse, though.

I love our DT and she does a great job. I felt it quite condescending to speak that way when she didn’t even know who our therapist was, yet she insulted her anyway. Ms. Snarky Evaluator then went on to say signs are a waste of time. I explained how he does more, and she said there is absolutely no way he can know what an abstract word like more means. Well, I don’t know if Bud fully defines more using a dictionary definition, but I do know that he signs more when he wants more food, more turns at his toy, or more of tackling daddy. I also know that within weeks of beginning to use the sign for more, he began saying more. Sure doesn’t seem like a waste of time to me. In fact, I remember crying tears of joy the first time Bud and I communicated back and forth, and more was our first.

Since she was not asking a lot of questions, I offered that while Buddy doesn’t speak, he definitely understands much of what we say as he follows directions and commands. She had the gall to insist that he does not know much of anything we say, but that he just follows cues from our body. I asked, “so whey I say ‘want to take a bath’ and use no signs or verbal cues and we are downstairs, and he goes to the stairs to go up to the bath, or runs to the bathroom if we are already upstairs, he doesn’t know I just said ‘wanna take a bath?’” She quickly retorted that it was probably because we ask at the same time each night. My inner Mama Bear is calling B.S. He doesn’t even take a bath every day, let alone at the same time.

I KNOW my boy understand me. I have countless examples, and more to add on each day. Once, Bud was playing with a puzzle on the floor, and I was telling my husband that I was going to leave for work now. I was not looking at, talking to, or cuing Bud, and he immediately got up and cried and reached his arms out for me because he did not want me to leave.  My inner Mama Bear snaps “Take That!” to Ms. Snarky Evaluator. This woman had never met my son, yet felt free to say everything we have done is a waste. She added that ”with a lot of hard work he has the potential to be teachable,”  though to what extent and with what quality she was unsure. I would not pretend to know more than a professional about speech techniques and such, but I do know more about my son. The other therapists know my son, too, and have seen much progress and been nothing but positive. They value my input as his parent and we work as a team.

I am so grateful that Ms. S.E. was not my first experience in the early intervention program. Her negativity and condescension would have pushed me over the edge at a time when I was so scared and confused, broken-hearted and overwhelmed. Instead, I didn’t let her get me down. I simply went through the motions with her to get the signature we needed to add weekly speech therapy for my son with a therapist who will actually care more about Buddy than spouting off her own credentials and discrediting the work done by others.

Ms. Snark did not say my son was unintelligent, but it felt like she was almost insinuating it. I feel this from people sometimes, people that do not know him well.  He cannot talk, or people just hear the phrase ”developmental delay” and automatically think he is slow or unintelligent. For the record, I would love him and embrace his unique strengths if he was cognitively disabled, and I believe all children with such a disability have their own strengths and intelligence. That being said, delayed does not mean he is not smart!  I want to focus on what he CAN do, not dwell on what he cannot. My son is delayed, yes, but he is also clever, sly, flirty, silly, sweet, stubborn, active, destructive, determined, loving…and very very loved.

As an end note, I have to add that the very next day, Bud picked up a picture of an apple from his PECS and said “apple” clear as day. He says it all day long, likely due to the rousing applause he gets each time. He has also said ball, book, and bub (bubbles), though not as frequently as the beloved apple. The same night as Snark night, he came to me with his jack-in-the-box, sat down next to me, popped it open, then signed more because he wanted me to help him close it so he could make it pop again, more play as we say in our house. Inner Mama Bear peeked out again and sang “nanny nanny boo boo” to Ms. Snark.

Related Posts Plugin for WordPress, Blogger...
Be Sociable, Share!

Tags: , ,
Be Sociable, Share!

About Jenny from the Block

I am a mother of two children, a wife and daughter, a friend and Christian...among many other things. My 2 year old has been diagnosed with PDD-NOS with an autism diagnosis looming on the horizen and my 7 year old daughter was diagnosed with SPD this summer. I work at a community mental health center and have a background in sociology as well. I enjoy reading, writing, yoga, board games with friends, movies. This whole process has been challenging, but we come such a long way. My favorite new positive mantra is "focus on what your child CAN do rather than dwell on what they cannot do...yet."

    Comments

  • tana


    I am so sorry that you had that experience. Sadly, it isn’t that uncommon. You did the right thing — as hard as it can be to break up with a therapist (that darned guilt can be tricky), parents need to do what is best for their children. Sometimes, parents, kids, and therapists need time to build a rapport, but if a therapist is late, doesn’t dedicate the full treatment time to you and your child, and treats you poorly, it’s time to move on. Just be honest when talking to the supervisors and hopefully everything should work out!

    (and frankly, I’m not sure that SLP knew what she was talking about. I know plenty of infants who use signs meaningfully — “more” and “all done” area usually 2 of the first.)

  • Sybil


    Sounds like your took this bad experience and made the best of it! Good for you for not letting an outside evaluator tell you about your child. As an evaluator of children with special needs, myself, I am constantly telling parents that they know their children best. Parents are the best resources, not tests, observations, etc. I have always held this perspective, but it has definitely been more important to me since raising my own child with sensory needs. Great job, Mama Bear!

  • niksmom


    Wow, Ms. S.E. needs to be reported to your state ASHA for bad practice. There is TONS of research (lots of it available at ASHA.org) which supports the exact OPPOSITE of what she was trying to tell you about signing and alternative/augmentative means of communicating. Also, she clearly doesn’t know the meaning of the phrase “presume competence.” I’m sorry you even had to waste your time with her.

  • Jill


    Your Buddy sounds a lot like my little guy. My son also likes to carry around/fling PECs cards more than use them ;-)
    We did sign language way before our son ever got an autism diagnosis just b/c it was the “in thing” to do at the time.
    When the pediatric specialist finally gave us the official diagnosis after 6 months of searching, she said it was great we had started sign so early as it was a way for him to communicate.
    The specialist also said, and I quote “it is clear he understands a lot of what is going on around him even though he does seem to always pay attention in an obvious way.”
    Sounds like your little boy is much the same way ;-) and boo hiss to Miss Snark.

  • jenny from the block


    Thanks ladies, I am loving your comments!

    This sentence is so tru…“it is clear he understands a lot of what is going on around him even though he does seem to always pay attention in an obvious way.”

    I think I should look into that ASHA thing. I have since learned she is lik this with many families but that apparently there are not a ton of people qualified for what she does (the evaluation piece is an extra credential) in our area and that is why they keep her on…there has to be someone else though!

  • Jacquie


    I am so glad to hear that you turned this bad situation into a learning experience. I remember when we started the whole process of therapies and diagnosis’s all the therapists informed us that the parent is the best resource because parents see things no one else does long before most other will.

  • Julie


    Oh boy, it is SOOO dangerous to say that a child doesn’t know what is going on around him/her. People who’ve made that mistake around my son have lived to regret it. Another vote for reporting this sorry excuse of a speech therapist!

  • EHCMom


    Definitely ditch Ms. Snarky. I’ve had an experience with a speech therapist that insisted that oral motor exercises do not help with speech, even though the expert at the children’s hospital in our State asks me every time she evaluates her, “is she getting oral motor exercises?” I kept asking again and again for two years for her to provide some exercises that I could do at home–she didn’t even have to do them during therapy, and she would not give them. When our daughter was diagnosed with SPD this summer and she began OT, they gave me a couple oral motor exercises to do at home, and within two weeks her speech had improved dramatically. Fortunately, the speech therapist we’ve been seeing the past two years is out, and we have a new therapist. If I hear the words “oral motor exercises don’t work” I just might bonk her on the head. Grrrr!

  • Heather Finnegan


    I’m sorry that is just AWFUL! She is an idiot! I have taught BOTH of my children to sign and “more” was the first one! And to not sign with them or use the PECS cards? I have an EC degree not SLP, but I think I might just know more than she does! Ridiculous!

  • Trisha Shipcott


    I am a speech and language pathologist specializing in early childhood. I am very passionate about all children becoming successful communicators. I am so sorry you had a bad experience. I frequently use signs with kids who do not use many words. It is a great bridge to oral language. I hope your experience with your regular therapist is a great one. I know how challenging the process can be. For this reason, created Little Talkers, a free speech and language resource for families and educators. You can check speech/language milestones and watch free videos designed to help you promote speech/language skills with your child. You can learn if your child might have a delay, what your next step is, how to get services, ways you can help, etc. I hope you and others can find it helpful. You can view it at http://www.littletalkers.com. You can contact me through this site if I can give you any more information. Thank you.

  • Jennifer


    Sounds like this person has a chip on her shoulder and may just not be the right person for the job. Her “assertions” likely have nothing to do with you or your child and more to do with her own personality or personal issues. While we want folks to tell us things about our kids that we may not pick up on, we don’t need someone who makes hasty assertions with nothing to back it up. I hope you can find someone else to help! Good luck!

    Leave a Comment

    Your email is never shared.
    Required fields are marked *